SECTION A – Foundations of Procurement (1–10)
1. What is procurement in the context of construction projects?
Explanation: Tests your understanding of basic definitions.
Answer:
Procurement is the process of selecting the most suitable strategy, form of contract, and supply chain to deliver a project’s objectives relating to time, cost, quality, and risk. It includes defining the scope, packaging the works, selecting the route (e.g., Traditional, D&B), and choosing the contractor or consultants.
2. What factors influence procurement strategy?
Explanation: Tests ability to advise clients.
Answer:
Project complexity, design maturity, risk allocation, client priorities, budget certainty, programme constraints, contractor market conditions, and need for early contractor involvement. I evaluate these factors and produce a recommendation aligned to client objectives.
3. Explain the difference between procurement strategy and tendering strategy.
Explanation: Common APC distinction.
Answer:
Procurement strategy = overall route to deliver the project (e.g., D&B).
Tendering strategy = how the contractor is selected (e.g., single-stage competitive tender).
4. What procurement routes have you used?
Explanation: Must give real project examples.
Answer:
Traditional (JCT SBC/Q), Design & Build (JCT D&B), Two-stage D&B, and Framework procurement. I advised based on design maturity and risk appetite.
5. Explain Traditional procurement.
Answer:
The client appoints designers to produce full design before tender. Contractor builds only. Offers strong cost certainty but longer pre-construction period.
6. Explain Design & Build procurement.
Answer:
Client provides Employer’s Requirements; contractor completes design and construction. Offers single point of responsibility and faster delivery, but reduces client design control.
7. What is Two-Stage Tendering?
Answer:
Stage 1 selects a contractor based on prelims, OH&P and qualitative criteria. Stage 2 develops design collaboratively and agrees a final contract sum. Useful when early contractor input is required.
8. What is Management Contracting?
Answer:
A management contractor is appointed early and manages work packages; does not carry construction risk. Suitable for fast-track projects.
9. What is Construction Management?
Answer:
The client appoints trade contractors directly. High risk for client but offers speed and flexibility.
10. How do government procurement rules differ from private sector?
Answer:
Public procurement must be transparent, non-discriminatory and follow regulated procedures (e.g., PCR 2015), including OJEU/Find-a-Tender notices. Private sector is more flexible.
SECTION B – Tendering Process (11–25)
11. What tendering methods do you know?
Answer:
Open tendering, selective/shortlisted tendering, negotiated tendering, two-stage tendering, framework call-offs, competitive dialogue (public sector).
12. What is the purpose of a pre-qualification questionnaire (PQQ)?
Answer:
To assess a contractor’s capability, financial standing, H&S record, and experience to ensure only competent tenderers progress.
13. What documents are included in a tender pack?
Answer:
Instructions to Tenderers, Form of Tender, Prelims, Drawings, Specifications, Bills of Quantities/Activity Schedules, Contract amendments, Employer’s Requirements, and Appendices.
14. What is the difference between Bills of Quantities and an Activity Schedule?
Answer:
BoQ: measured items with detailed quantities (JCT/traditional).
Activity Schedule: contractor-generated activities with lump sums (NEC).
BoQ better for valuation; activity schedule transfers risk to contractor.
15. What is a tender addendum?
Answer:
Issued to clarify or correct tender documents. Must be acknowledged by tenderers and recorded in tender queries log.
16. How do you ensure fairness during tendering?
Answer:
All tenderers receive identical information, clearly defined deadlines, no private discussions, responses to queries shared anonymously, and strict adherence to instructions to tender.
17. What should be in Instructions to Tenderers?
Answer:
Submission requirements, tender period, clarification process, format, evaluation criteria, site visit details, and required declarations.
18. How do you assess tender returns?
Answer:
Compliance check → arithmetic check → technical assessment → commercial analysis → risk review → reconciliation → scoring matrix → recommendation report.
19. What is abnormally low tender?
Answer:
A tender price significantly below others or industry norms. Must be queried formally to ensure deliverability and avoid contractor insolvency risk.
20. How do you manage tender queries?
Answer:
Maintain a tender queries log, consolidate responses, respond formally via addenda, ensure anonymity, and track against deadlines.
21. What is tender evaluation weighting?
Answer:
Allocation of percentages to price vs quality criteria, e.g., 60/40. Must reflect client priorities.
22. Give an example of tender evaluation you performed.
Answer:
I evaluated four D&B tenders by comparing prelims breakdowns, key risks, programme, and compliance. I identified a £450k design gap and corrected it, ensuring fair comparison.
23. What are post-tender clarifications?
Answer:
Questions issued to tenderers after submission to clarify assumptions—without changing tender price unfairly.
24. What is post-tender negotiation?
Answer:
Negotiations with lowest or preferred tenderer to refine price, design details, or programme. Must maintain transparency and audit trail.
25. How do you prepare a tender report?
Answer:
Summarise process, analysis, tender comparison, risk items, queries, compliance, and recommendations. Client signs off before contract award.
SECTION C – Risk, Commercial & Legal (26–40)
26. What risks affect procurement choices?
Answer:
Design complexity, ground conditions, supply chain stability, time constraints, and cost volatility. Procurement route allocates/manage these risks.
27. What is risk transfer in procurement?
Answer:
Allocating responsibility for specific risks to the party best able to manage them. Example: D&B contracts transfer design coordination risk to the contractor.
28. What is the danger of transferring too much risk?
Answer:
Premium pricing, strategic under-pricing, increased claims, or contractor failure.
29. What commercial checks do you undertake before awarding a contract?
Answer:
Financial health check (credit rating, liquidity analysis), insurances, capacity, references, and supply chain robustness.
30. Explain single-stage vs two-stage tendering.
Answer:
Single-stage: full design complete; competitive lump sum.
Two-stage: contractor appointed early; price developed collaboratively.
Used depending on design completeness and time pressures.
31. What is the impact of procurement on programme?
Answer:
Traditional longer pre-construction; D&B faster overall; two-stage allows early contractor input; frameworks speed up selection.
32. What are key legal issues in tendering?
Answer:
Formation of a contract, tender validity period, duty to treat tenderers equally, confidentiality, withdrawal of tenders, and potential for tendering negligence claims.
33. What is bid rigging?
Answer:
Illegal collusion between bidders to fix prices or outcomes. Must be reported and procurement halted.
34. What is a framework agreement?
Answer:
A pre-procured list of suppliers available for call-offs, avoiding full tender each time.
35. What is a mini-competition?
Answer:
Competitive process among framework suppliers for a specific project.
36. Explain OJEU/Find-a-Tender thresholds.
Answer:
Public projects above financial thresholds must follow regulated tender procedures (open, restricted, competitive dialogue).
37. What are selection vs award criteria?
Selection criteria = tenderer capability.
Award criteria = project-specific offer.
38. Explain MEAT (Most Economically Advantageous Tender).
Answer:
Best balance of cost and quality considering whole-life value.
39. What is front-loading in a tender?
Answer:
Contractor artificially inflates early items to improve cash flow. Must be checked and corrected.
40. How do you deal with an unqualified tender?
Answer:
Clarify reasons, advise client of risks, request re-submission if appropriate, or disqualify if tenderer materially failed to follow instructions.
SECTION D – Practical Experience & Examples (41–50)
41. Describe a time you led a procurement exercise.
Answer:
I led procurement for a £12m D&B school project: prepared tender docs, managed tender queries, performed evaluation, ran clarifications, and produced the tender report. My recommendation was accepted, reducing programme by 8 weeks.
42. Describe a procurement challenge you faced.
Answer:
Supply chain volatility caused two bidders to withdraw. I reassessed the market, advised using a negotiated tender with a known contractor, and secured value while maintaining programme.
43. How did you add value during tendering?
Answer:
I identified overlapping contingencies in prelims and design risk allowances. Through clarification, I achieved £230k savings without reducing scope.
44. How do you ensure auditability of tendering?
Answer:
Maintain a tender file, record queries, minutes, decisions, clarifications, scoring sheets, and use e-tendering platforms with date/time stamping.
45. Give an example of managing tender risk.
Answer:
I ran a pre-tender risk workshop identifying key risks (façade, MEP). This informed tender adjustments and reduced post-tender claims.
46. How do you deal with late tenders?
Answer:
Follow ITT rules. Typically, reject unless client instructs otherwise and fairness can be demonstrated.
47. How do you evaluate quality submissions?
Answer:
Use scoring matrices, weighted criteria, blind scoring, panel moderation, and clear evidence-based justification.
48. Explain your role in a two-stage tender negotiation.
Answer:
I facilitated design workshops, developed the contract sum, resolved provisional sums, and validated supply chain quotations to achieve a realistic GMP.
49. How do you handle contractor clarifications that reduce price but increase risk?
Answer:
I assess implications, advise client on risk trade-off, negotiate wording amendments, or reject if risk unmanageable.
50. Why should RICS approve you in Procurement & Tendering?
Answer:
I have led multiple procurement exercises, demonstrated rigorous and ethical tender management, provided clear advice aligned to client objectives, and ensured transparency, fairness, and value for money consistent with RICS professional standards.
No comments:
Post a Comment